Home›FWJ Takeaway›Tax disputes›R&D Tax Credit investigations›R&D tax relief claims: what Environmental Services Ltd v HMRC says about evidence and technological advancement

A recent First-tier Tribunal decision provides an important reminder that genuine innovation does not automatically amount to qualifying research and development for tax purposes.

In Environmental Services Ltd v Revenue and Customs [2026] UKFTT 1301 (TC), the Tribunal accepted that the company had undertaken genuine experimental work and that the employee leading much of the technical activity was a competent professional with extensive practical expertise.

The R&D tax relief claim still failed.

The difficulty was that the company had not established that its projects were directed towards an advance in overall scientific or technological knowledge or capability, rather than improvements to its own business operations. It also failed to provide sufficient evidence to establish how much of its expenditure was attributable to qualifying R&D.

For businesses making an R&D claim, or challenging an HMRC decision to refuse one, the judgment shows why the technical case and the financial evidence need to support each other.


Why did Environmental Services’ R&D tax relief claim fail?

Environmental Services Limited operated a waste collection and transportation business. It claimed R&D tax relief for two projects involving the handling and transportation of waste.

The projects involved practical work concerning the loading, agitation, separation, pumping and unloading of waste materials. The company argued that the work involved technological uncertainty and experimentation which went beyond routine waste-management activities.

HMRC disagreed and issued closure notices disallowing the company’s R&D claims for the accounting periods ending 31 July 2020 and 31 July 2021.

The company appealed.

  • The First-tier Tribunal accepted that genuine work had been carried out to improve the company’s operations.
  • It also accepted that experimentation and practical problem-solving had taken place.

That was not enough.

For R&D tax purposes, the relevant guidelines require a project to seek an advance in science or technology. The advance must relate to overall knowledge or capability in the relevant field, rather than simply an improvement in the claimant company’s own processes.

The Tribunal concluded that Environmental Services had not shown that its projects were directed towards that type of wider technological advance.

Instead, the evidence demonstrated practical problem-solving aimed at addressing operational and commercial challenges within the business.

That distinction proved decisive.


What does an R&D project need to show about technological advancement?

The Tribunal considered the statutory R&D regime together with the applicable guidelines on the meaning of research and development for tax purposes.

A qualifying project must seek to achieve an advance in science or technology. That can include an appreciable improvement to an existing process, product or service through scientific or technological change. However, a product or process does not qualify simply because it performs better than what the particular company previously used. The project needs to be considered against the overall knowledge or capability available in the relevant field.

That makes the baseline important.

  • A claimant should be able to identify what was already known or available before the project began and explain what technological advance the project was intended to achieve.
  • It should also be possible to identify the scientific or technological uncertainty which prevented that advance from being readily achieved using existing knowledge.

In Environmental Services, the Tribunal found that this connection had not been established sufficiently.

The projects may have produced useful improvements for the company, but the evidence did not demonstrate an advance in the underlying field of waste-management technology within the meaning of the R&D rules.

This is an important distinction for businesses preparing claims.

A project can be commercially innovative, expensive, technically difficult and highly valuable to the company without necessarily qualifying as R&D for tax purposes.


How important is evidence from a competent professional?

Evidence from a competent professional can be very important.

  • Environmental Services did not lose its appeal because the Tribunal considered its technical employee insufficiently qualified or experienced.
  • The Tribunal expressly accepted that Mr Aiden Race was a competent professional with extensive practical expertise.
  • It also accepted the witnesses as truthful.

That makes the case particularly useful.

A business cannot assume that establishing the credibility of the person carrying out the work will establish the R&D claim itself. The competent professional should ideally be able to explain the technological context in which the project took place.

That includes identifying the relevant field, the baseline level of scientific or technological knowledge, the advance being sought and the uncertainties which prevented that advance from being readily deduced.

The evidence should also explain what activities were undertaken to resolve those uncertainties.

In a disputed HMRC enquiry, technical evidence can therefore be much stronger if it is organised around the R&D tests rather than being limited to a description of how difficult or innovative the project felt to those involved.

FWJ’s R&D Tax Credit Investigation service deals specifically with HMRC challenges involving project eligibility, technological uncertainty, competent-professional evidence and supporting expenditure records.


Does an R&D tax claim need contemporaneous documents to succeed?

Not necessarily.

This is an important qualification arising from the judgment.

The Tribunal expressly stated that its decision was not based simply on Environmental Services’ lack of contemporaneous documentation. The Tribunal accepted the witnesses as truthful and considered their evidence at its highest.

It also accepted, on the facts of this particular case, evidence that the technical plan for the projects had effectively been held in the competent professional’s head rather than being recorded in a formal written project plan.

The claim still failed because the evidence as a whole did not establish the statutory requirements. However, the absence of contemporary records did make the company’s position more difficult. Without clear documentation, it was harder for the Tribunal to assess precisely what activities had taken place, which technological uncertainties were being addressed and how particular expenditure related to those activities.

Businesses should therefore distinguish between something being an absolute legal requirement and something being extremely useful evidence.

A formal R&D document created before work begins may not always be mandatory.

But records created while a project is underway can make it considerably easier to demonstrate later what the business was attempting to achieve and why the work fell within the R&D regime.

Project notes, test results, technical discussions, failed approaches and records explaining the problems being addressed can all help establish the story of the project.

This is particularly important where HMRC opens an enquiry several years later and the people involved are being asked to reconstruct what happened from memory.


Why did the company also fail to prove its qualifying R&D expenditure?

Even if a company establishes that qualifying R&D occurred, it still needs to show which expenditure qualifies for relief.

Environmental Services faced a separate evidential problem on this part of its claim. The company had claimed percentages of employee salary costs on the basis of the amount of time individuals were said to have spent on the R&D projects. For one accounting period, it claimed 80% of Mr Race’s salary and 10% of the salary costs of other individuals. Different percentages were claimed for the following period.

However, the Tribunal was not provided with time records or detailed workings showing how those percentages had been calculated.

Other claimed expenditure included maintenance, materials and equipment hire. Again, the evidence did not sufficiently establish how individual costs related to qualifying R&D activities.

The Tribunal rejected the suggestion that it could simply estimate qualifying expenditure on a just and reasonable basis without an adequate evidential foundation.

The taxpayer had the burden of proving the amount which qualified.

This creates a useful practical distinction.

A business needs to prove both that qualifying R&D occurred and that the particular costs included in the claim were attributable to that activity.

Strong technical evidence cannot necessarily repair weak expenditure evidence.

Likewise, detailed cost schedules cannot turn a non-qualifying project into R&D.

Our guidance on common R&D tax claim mistakes explains why HMRC frequently challenges claims where technical descriptions and the underlying calculation of expenditure do not align.


What should businesses do when HMRC challenges an R&D tax relief claim?

An HMRC challenge should first be broken down into the particular issues being disputed.

HMRC may dispute whether there was a qualifying technological advance, whether genuine scientific or technological uncertainty existed, whether the individual relied upon was a competent professional, or whether the expenditure calculation is supported.

Those are different issues and should normally be addressed separately.

Where technological eligibility is challenged, the evidence should explain the project by reference to the R&D criteria rather than relying only on broad descriptions of innovation.

The relevant field should be identified. The business should explain the existing baseline of knowledge or capability, the advance sought and why a competent professional could not readily deduce how to achieve it. The activities undertaken to resolve that uncertainty should then be connected to the claim.

The expenditure analysis needs the same discipline. Staff time, consumables and other claimed costs should be capable of being linked to the qualifying activities on a reasonable evidential basis. Where records are incomplete, that does not automatically mean an appeal cannot succeed. But the company still carries the burden of establishing its entitlement on the balance of probabilities.

The practical lesson from Environmental Services is therefore not simply to produce more paperwork.

It is to make sure the evidence answers the legal questions HMRC and, if necessary, the Tribunal will actually have to decide.

Francis Wilks & Jones advises companies facing HMRC R&D tax credit enquiries, amendments and repayment demands. We can review the technical and financial basis of a disputed claim, help businesses respond to HMRC and advise on appeals where an HMRC decision remains disputed.

The judgment provides a useful reminder of the central point:

Genuine innovation is not enough by itself. An R&D claim needs evidence showing the qualifying technological advance and evidence supporting the expenditure claimed.

Key contacts

Andy Lynch

Andy Lynch

Partner (Non-solicitor)

Khaliq Martin

Khaliq Martin

Senior Paralegal

Anita Sharma

Anita Sharma

Senior Associate

View full team

Case studies

View all case studies

Contact us in confidence